Can you be honest? Part 1 of 3

See that manuscript in front of you? It is time to share it. Now, don’t be afraid, you knew this day was going to come. You and I both know you wrote this book because you wanted to share it with the world. Now it is time to share it with a few readers. Readers are people who agree to read your early work and understand you are still in the rough draft phase. “Rough Draft Phase?” you say. Yes, I am afraid so. Even if you think your book is perfect in every way, trust me, it is far from perfect. It is not humanly possible to step back from your writing and make an honest assessment of the time line, awkwardness of words, or edits. You need a pair of fresh eyes to read it and be honest with you about the broad strokes of your masterpiece.

It is very hard to find honest readers. Your mother or cousin is not going to be honest with you if your book stinks. I am telling you from experience, they love you—therefore they will not crush you. You must find three people who love to read. They should be readers in your genre. If person loves to read biographies and you have written a self-help book on snail mating, they will not enjoy your book. I repeat—they will not enjoy it. A person who is an avid reader in romance would be okay reading a biography but you need to stay within a person’s normal preference range of reading, if possible.

When you ask someone to be a reader, you need to be specific about what you need. Tell them you will be publishing this book and need to know what works and what doesn’t. Tell them to be brutal. Tell them you will spend countless hours editing and anything they can do to help you now will save so much time later. Tell them you have a thick skin and not to worry about hurting your feelings. Make them promise to be honest.

Print the book out for your reader (two page format), give them a big red pen, and slowly back away. If the reader comes back in a week with a few red marks and says, “The book is great, I love it!” say, “Thank You” and find another reader. The copy SHOULD come back with all kinds of red marks, questions, and suggestions. I don’t care who you are, or how many years you have under your belt as a writer, you will have some problems with your manuscript. A good reader will point out it is impossible for a character to pick a tick off of a dog in chapter 14 when both her thumbs were severed in the tragic accident in chapter 2!

Categories: Self-Publishing | Tags: , , , , , | 9 Comments

Post navigation

9 thoughts on “Can you be honest? Part 1 of 3

  1. I am peeking through your site, Reba! Always something interesting and helpful!

    It is difficult for most early readers to read with a critical eye. I am one of them. My first readers were like that. “Everything is beautiful!” thet would say. But then, I kept sharing with others and others, and boy, were they critical! More than I wanted them to be. I had to make many changes and bring in new ideas. If I kept the book for another year, I could continue making changes, but I don’t want to keep working on it for years. By Xmas, I want it out

    Next few free moments I have, I’ll check out your book. I like your cover.

    All best!

  2. Thank you Katina! I wish you well on your new book. I agree, I think I could have worked on the darn thing for the rest of my life…but deadlines call!

  3. Greats comments and site.

  4. Reblogged this on Authors Helping Authors Resource Site and commented:
    Reba Ponder Weiss has written a great 3 part series on her blog and we found it to be a great match for the content we try to deliver here…thank you Reba, and enjoy, we hope you find an AHA moment with us! Next Friday we will reblog part 2 and then again the following Friday for part 3 or jump over to Reba’s blog if you can’t wait!

  5. m.muhlenkamp

    Great post Reba! It is hard at first to find the right people to read your manuscript, like you said, they love you and they don’t want to hurt your feelings. But, once you find those golden readers, their constructive criticism is so worth the effort. It makes your manuscript better, which in turn allows you to learn from mistakes and become a better writer.

  6. Great advise. I sent a short story to my sister, a cousins, college classmates and friends. Guess who said this was a la-dee-da story with no excitemet, no passion and I can do better. My sister, the faithful critic. My friends and classmates thought it was terrific except for a few typos.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at

%d bloggers like this: